After razor-thin vote margins decided the fate of the tax cap ballot question in two local school districts, both are headed to a recount.

The question failed by just three votes in the Wilton-Lyndeborough Cooperative School District, while it passed by 12 votes in the Jaffrey-Rindge Cooperative School District. A House of Representatives seat representing Jaffrey, Rindge and Dublin is also slated for a recount.

Ballot Question 2 concerns a tax cap on public schools, which limits property tax growth for school districts to the prior year’s amount, adjusted for inflation and new construction, and caps administrative spending at six percent of total school district appropriations. It required a 60% approval threshold to pass.

Wilton and Lyndeborough had the majority in favor but only reached 1,626 of the 1,629 needed district-wide to pass. In Wilton, 1,102 people voted yes to 759 no. In Lyndeborough, 524 voted yes to 331 no.

Three votes shy of approval, 12 district residents signed a petition for a recount. Two residents from Lyndeborough and 10 from Wilton, including Select Board Member Frank Edelbult, signed the petition, according to the petition provided by the Wilton Town Clerk Jane Farrell.

Farrell said unlike most recounts, which are performed by the Secretary of State’s office in Concord, the Wilton-Lyndeborough school board will hold and facilitate the recount in accordance with the Secretary of State’s guidelines.

Although she must be present because the town clerk holds all the ballots, Farrell cannot participate in the process.

“I’ve never had this situation arise,” she said.

The district’s business administrator, Kristie LaPlante, spoke on behalf of the school board on Monday, and said the school board and administrators were not surprised by the petition for a recount given how close the vote was.

While the school board will facilitate the recount, they have asked registered voters to volunteer for the recount after concerns were shared about the board’s partiality to the issue. LaPlante said the goal is to “maintain transparency throughout the process.”

Since the bill to place the tax cap question on the ballot was passed by the state legislature this summer, it has caused confusion for school districts heading into budget season. LaPlante said the budget committee instructed the administration to budget as if the tax cap did not pass. Now, they’ll wait to continue until after the recount.

“We’re very much in limbo right now,” LaPlante said.

The recount will take place Tuesday at 6:30 p.m. at the Wilton-Lyndeborough Cooperative Middle High School cafeteria.

Jaffrey-Rindge yet to be scheduled

A recount has also been requested in Jaffrey-Rindge, though it has yet to be scheduled.

With both towns combined, the tax cap question passed the 60% threshold by just 12 votes. In Jaffrey, the vote was 1,267 yes votes to 1,122 no votes, and in Rindge, 1,821 yes votes to 918 no.

Lisa Wiley, chair of the Jaffrey-Rindge School Board and supervisor of the checklist in Rindge, said in both towns the recount was requested by private citizens, not the district or the school board.

The timing of the recount is still a bit murky for the district, said Wiley, complicated by the fact that the ballots for both Jaffrey and Rindge will be held for a recount of the House of Representatives Cheshire District 18 race until Nov. 20.

Wiley said the district has been told it will receive the ballots after the recount, though the exact timing has not been announced. The School Board must conduct the recount no earlier than five calendar days and no later than 10 days after the state’s recount. It will likely take place around the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.

Wiley said that whether or not the recount results in a flip of the vote, the results sent a clear message to the school board.

“It would allow us breathing room, but even if the recount comes back in favor of the school district budget, it still means the majority of voters need a change in how school funding happens,” said Wiley. “We have a situation in New Hampshire that’s made property taxes untenable, and the school districts have to carry that, and it’s pitted children against taxpayers.”

Wiley said at the same time that more than half of the school districts in the state — 91 out of 168 — adopted the tax cap, New Hampshire was also part of the Democratic surge, which turned both the state Senate and House to Democratic majorities.

“I hope fresh faces will come with creative solutions at the legislative level,” said Wiley.

Cheshire 18 race prompts recount

The two House of Representatives seats for Cheshire 18 were among those that saw a shakeup in the Nov. 3 blue wave, with Republican incumbents Jim Qualey and Rita Mattson ousted by Democratic candidates Allen Davis and Rory Lovett Sherman, though the votes were almost even across all four candidates.

Davis and Lovett Sherman were declared the winners with 2,879 votes and 2,869 votes, respectively.

Qualey, in particular, came in just behind Lovett Sherman by a three-vote margin, with 2,866 votes, and requested a recount. Mattson received 2,808 votes.

“It’s three votes out of 6,240 cast, so I’m obligated to make the request to make sure the count was accurate,” said Qualey. “If it had been the other way around, and I had one by three votes, I would have fully expected the next-highest candidate to also request a recount.”

Davis said he respected the right to request a recount, particularly given the closeness of the race, though said it has been a strain to wait for the recount to affirm results.

“Personally, it’s been very difficult and stressful for me to have to wait 17 days after the election to know for sure whether I’m going to be able to represent the people of Dublin, Jaffrey and Rindge,” said Davis. “Regardless of the outcome, I believe it’s imperative that the Secretary of State’s office figures out a way to reduce the amount of time for candidates in a recount to have to wait.”

Qualey said he plans to attend and observe the recount in Concord on Nov. 20, as will Mattson, though she said she does not expect a change in results in her race, which had a wider margin.

Qualey said he participated in a 2022 recount as a counter and said it’s a thorough process.

“We owe it to the voters to make sure the results are accurate, is the long and short of it,” said Qualey. “It’s a human process, and human processes are prone to error to some degree.”