Christina Rubio-Sprague presents plans to turn the former Catholic church and rectory on Maple Street into five housing units and an office and workshop.
Christina Rubio-Sprague presents plans to turn the former Catholic church and rectory on Maple Street into five housing units and an office and workshop. Credit: Staff photo by Ashley Saari—

The former Catholic church and rectory on Maple Street was back before the Wilton Zoning Board of Adjustment Tuesday to ask for a variance to be renovated into apartments and an office and workshop.

The proposal is identical to one already approved by the board in 2017, which lapsed before the work was finished. It calls for the rectory to be turned into two, three-bedroom apartments, to renovate the church basement into three apartments and to turn the upstairs into an office and workshop for the owner’s use.

Because the owner is not intending to live on the property, the board found that the office and workshop would be commercial uses, which are not allowed in the district. The proposal also exceeds the amount of units allowed on a single lot.

When board members approved the project in 2017, they made a condition of approval that work on the building begin within two years. Since the deadline for the start date has passed, and the owners must seek approvals all over again.

“This is a case that is essentially the same as what was requested five years ago, that was granted, but never acted upon, and expired,” said ZBA Chair Neil Faiman.

All but one board member who heard the case on Tuesday was also on the board during the previous hearings. Board member Peter Howd, who was not a member at the time, said while other members may have broader context because they heard the case before, he needed to start from scratch. He requested additional information, including a site plan of the grounds, a proposed layout for the apartments and a parking plan.

“We need to evaluate it in 2022, not 2017,” Howd said.

Howd also expressed concerns about the proposed commercial uses, particularly the workshop, and other potential future uses, and whether it would be disruptive to the neighborhood.

“The thing about a variance is it stays with the property,” Howd said. Even if the board finds the currently proposed use acceptable, there may be issues with other commercial uses in the future, Howd said, including the church’s small lot size and lack of parking.

The sacristy, where the workshop and office are planned to go, is about 3,980 square feet. That was a lot of commercial space to provide parking for, Howd said, even though the current proposal is that the commercial space would be for the owner’s personal use and would not have regular walk-in customers or clients off the street.

“Regardless of how it is used, you’re required to have a certain number of parking spaces,” Howd said.

Christina Rubio-Sprague, who currently owns the building, said there has been a parking layout showing up to 17 parking spaces on the lot.

Neighbor Heika Siegert, who lives on Maple Street, said she also had concerns relating to noise from the workshop, and whether there was any plan to alter the exterior of the historic church.

“I want to know our cute little neighborhood will remain peaceful,” Siegert said.

Rubio-Sprague said the workshop would be used for upcycling and furniture repair. There would be no regular employees, and it would be “low-intensity activities” with no large machinery, although it would include the use of power tools. There is no plan to change the exterior of the church, and maintaining the facade was a condition of the 2017 approval. Rubio-Sprague said she was prepared to accept at least the same conditions attached to the approval as it was in 2017.

Although the majority of the board toured the property in 2017, at the request of Howd, the board agreed to schedule a site visit on Oct. 8 at 9 a.m. to view the property, located at 47 Maple St. The board continued the hearing until its next meeting on Oct. 11 at the Florence Rideout Elementary School at 7:30 p.m.