Peterborough deserves accountability
We are the parents of Jack Hutchings, the young man who was shot and killed by an off-duty Peterborough Police officer on July 5. The investigation into that evening is ongoing, and while we remain open to what may have happened, we believe the community should be concerned about the processes the town and the police department are following.
Your paper has published stories about the incident, including one on Oct. 5 reporting that the officer involved returned to duty on Sept. 21. Peterborough Police Chief Guinard has not explained why he reinstated the officer. When your Oct. 5 story ran, the Attorney General’s office confirmed its investigation was ongoing, and that remains true. Chief Guinard also has not explained why his department seemingly disregarded its own use-of-force policy, which states, “The chief of police shall place the officer on administrative leave pending the completion of a review board and any other pending investigations.” It also states that it applies to on-duty and off-duty officers.
The Peterborough Select Board, which oversees the police department, has shown no visible interest in holding it accountable. They should ask the same questions and, if they find no justification for disregarding the policy, take appropriate action. Select Board members owe area residents a duty to ensure the police follow policies adopted to protect the public.
To obtain answers, we submitted a right-to-know request for records related to the return-to-duty decision on Oct. 19, and the town initially said it would provide the requested records by Nov. 11. On that day, the town pushed back its own deadline to Nov. 13 and again to Nov. 20. The lack of transparency and urgency on the Select Board’s part should concern residents about the fair administration of justice in their area.
