
Perched along Forest Road on the shore of Zephyr Lake, a modest red house holds more than two centuries of local history, architectural quirks, and family tradition.
For more than 50 years, the home has served as a summer and holiday retreat for the Sutterlin family. Yet its story dates back to the early 1800s — and begins half a mile up the hill.

According to the Greenfield Historical Society, the structure originally stood on Woodland Hill, where a young couple, Hugh Abbott and Minerva Cragin Abbott, lived. In 1826, at age 24, Hugh Abbott left Greenfield to spend the winter digging canals for textile mills in Lowell, Massachusetts. Before leaving, he arranged to move the house down the hill to its current roadside location so Minerva and their children could live across the street from her relatives in the yellow brick Cragin family homestead.

At the time, Zephyr Lake was known as Cragin Pond. According to Lenny Cornwell of the Greenfield Historical Society, town officials renamed several bodies of water in the late 19th century, likely to appeal to Massachusetts tourists arriving by train, turning Cragin Pond into Zephyr Lake and Gould Pond into Sunset Lake.
The Cragin lineage traces back to John Cragin, a Scottish soldier captured by British forces after the Battle of Dunbar in 1650, who was sent to the American colonies as an indentured servant before earning his freedom. The relocated red house passed down through the Abbott and Cragin descendants for generations, eventually coming to belong to Mary Varnum and her family.

Colonial craftsmanship
The house originally consisted of one large room with a high ceiling, later split into a living room and dining room, with a second floor added later. The two front rooms have original wide-plank floors, and the dining room has rare “King’s Board” wainscoting made from old-growth trees that, by law, belonged to King George III but that many colonists in the region cut down anyway and used to build their homes.

The living room has an unusual, one-log-deep Federal-style fireplace, while the dining room has a fieldstone fireplace that was added later.
Over time, the family built a barn and connected it to the house with outbuildings. While the outbuildings are gone, the original barn remains, including its horse stalls and a tiny outhouse in the back corner.

A diplomatic retreat
In 1972, Arthur Varnum and his wife, Aileen, sold the red house to James Sutterlin and his family. The Varnums built a new lake house on land north of the red house, where they retired.
Sutterlin was a retired diplomat who had achieved the rank of assistant secretary of state and also served at the United Nations. According to Denise Sutterlin Fox, her parents found the Monadnock region through friends in the State Department Foreign Service, many of whom had homes in Hancock.
“There used to be a ton of retired State Department people around here,” Fox recalled. “I especially remember visiting the (Cecil) Lyons family, in Hancock; they had big old homes on the lake.”

The Sutterlins had previously rented other houses in the area, including on Lake Nubanusit, but something about the red house appealed to Denise’s mother, Betty.
“They had been looking for a while, and this came up, and it had its pros and cons, being so old, and being right on the road, but my mom really wanted it. It was really special to her,” Denise said.
Fox, who now lives in Peterborough, remembers spending every summer at the red house from her teenage years, swimming and boating on the lake and hiking the nearby mountains. The Sutterlins also gathered at the house for the holidays, and Denise, who is one of four siblings, remembers cross-country skiing through the woods on Woodland Hill and skating on Zephyr Lake.

While the house looks modest from the road, it is deceptively large, as the Abbott and Varnum families added on several times over the years.
“There are six bedrooms, so that we could fit a lot of people. When we all got married, the house would be just bursting at Christmas when we were all here,” Denise said.

Back in 1975, when Denise’s parents bought the property, the house’s drinking water came from Zephyr Lake. Fox recalls that her father, concerned about drinking straight from the lake, put in a springhouse on the shore.
“You would lift this lid off a hole in the ground, and there was a spring down there, and my sister and I would haul buckets of water up the stairs to the house. We kept it in a big, round metal can with a spigot, and we would leave it out here on the back porch, and that was our drinking water,” Fox said.
In the early years, the family continued to pump lake water up the hill for bathing and laundry. Later, Denise’s father had a well dug.
The Foxes and the Sutterlin siblings have maintained and updated the house over the years, upgrading the electricity, replacing the roof, and installing a new septic system, but the house still feels like a 1960s summer cottage. The kitchen includes a wood-fired iron stove, which the family fired up in the winter, and a screened-in porch on the back of the house overlooks the lake.
Denise’s sister now owns the house, which is occasionally offered as a seasonal vacation rental.


Denise’s husband, Steve Fox, who has done many of the house’s repairs over the years, remembers replacing the dock every year after the ice shifted it.
“It was just a wooden deck on cinderblocks, so the ice always knocked it down. That was a spring chore, every year,” Steve said.
Stone steps in the backyard lead down a steep hill to a deck overlooking Zephyr Lake. Denise recalls building the steps with her mother.
“My mom and I dug into the bank, and we found all these boulders, and turned them around, and we built the steps,” Fox said. “I don’t know how we did it, but we did.”
Later, the family added railings to the deck and a wide, sloped trail to make the lake accessible.
The dock is gone, but the wide deck on the water, which has a view of North Pack, is where the family and guests spend much of their time in the summer.
“It’s a really special place,” Denise Fox said. “We still love it.”








