When Sue Chollet moved in as the first resident of Nubanusit Neighborhood & Farm in Peterborough in 2007, she had a large barn built for her horses with “horse porches” and a pasture in the back. Never imagining a world without the barn, Chollet always took photos of her horses and rarely of the beautiful structure they called home.

“That’s the problem. Plenty of horse pictures. No barn pictures,” Chollet said.

Early on the morning of July 29, the barn was destroyed when a fire broke out. The horse barn was being used for storage at the time, and the fire did not spread. No one was injured.

“It looked like it was shooting lava out, and it was flying up and over into the air,” said Venessa Calabrese, a resident of the neighborhood. Chunks of embers flew over the property and close to nearby houses.

On Wednesday, Fire Chief Ed Walker said the cause is not suspicious. While the investigation continues, he said officials are looking into stained shingles stored in the building, which can overheat without proper care.

Now, all that stands is the hollow post-and-beam structure of what was Chollet’s barn, and the inescapable smell of smoke and embers.

“The importance was that it was this extraordinary house for my horses,” she said.

Fond memories

Chollet lived in Nubanusit Neighborhood, an environmentally conscious co-housing community, for 17 years and shared many memories with her neighbors there.

Traditionally, the barn housed up to three horses, which Chollet cared for with the help of the neighborhood children.

By waking up before the rest of their families in the summer and keeping the barn clean and organized, the kids earned horse riding lessons from Chollet.

“It was a community resource, a shared resource, and Sue really shared with the neighborhood by giving the riding lessons and teaching kids to care for the horses,” said Naomi Tucker, a resident of the neighborhood.

Chollet’s brother died last year, but she fondly remembers his persistence when visiting to help take care of her horses.

“He insisted whenever I came out to do the morning barn, to come out and help me, and it was just a wonderful time together,” she said.

In the wintertime, when her kids came to visit, Chollet remembers that on cold and boring days they would stretch a net across the barn and play badminton.

“And the horses would watch,” she said, laughing.

As Chollet got older, she donated her last horse to a young girl in Dublin.

“She’s still riding him and taking him to horse shows and just loving him, which is nice,” Chollet said.

Once the barn was no longer used as a home for horses, the building became a farm store run by Nubi River Farm.

Tucker said the transition from horses to vegetables in the barn was possible thanks to Chollet’s commitment to cleanliness.

For five years, Nubi River Farm leased land from the neighborhood and sold produce out of the barn. In 2026, the couple running the farm started Homeplace Farm and moved to family-owned land, according to the farm’s website.

At the time of the fire, the barn was being used for storage. Chollet said 17 bales of hay for the property’s cows and sheep were stored there.

Calabrese said the barn also held equipment for a new project to bring clean water to the fields, along with materials from recent repairs to some of the houses on the property.

Chollet recently moved to RiverMead after her kids raised concerns about her health, but she still visits the community she called home for almost two decades.

Once the structure is taken down and the insurance money comes through, Chollet hopes the neighborhood will organize to build a new building for the group to use.

Returning to the root of the Nubanusit Neighborhood’s values, Chollet said, “I hope that that is a whole community decision.”